We limit your risk with diligence.
Companies often consult with us, before litigation, on employment-related investigations. These issues run the gamut from sexual harassment claims to discrimination claims to personnel file requests. These challenges all present varying degrees of risk but also opportunity if properly handed. We find it is essential to quickly understand the situation so that damage can be avoided or mitigated.
Companies hire Cronkhite Counsel to investigate employee claims of alleged misconduct, including employee claims that a co-worker, supervisor, or owner discriminated against or harassed the employee. There is good reason to do so.
In 2023, American employees filed approximately 81,000 discrimination and sexual harassment claims with the U.S. Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC). In the recent past, the majority of those claims have involved discrimination or retaliation based on an employee’s disability, race, or sex (including sexual harassment).
While companies cannot eliminate discrimination and harassment claims against them, they can do a lot to reduce those claims by following best practices. Best practices include promptly responding to, and investigating, employee claims of misconduct. The company should quickly obtain written statements from the alleged victim and perpetrator, and later interview all witnesses to ascertain what occurred according to third-party sources. Company video and audio systems can also prove crucial.
Once the employer gathers all relevant information, we consult with our clients to advise on the best course of action moving forward. Depending on the evidence, appropriate steps may involve no action at all, suspension, or termination. But above all, the company should ensure the complainants are heard, their claims are professionally and promptly investigation, and the complainants are notified of the results.
Companies sometimes do not involve attorneys in these investigations because they underestimate the financial exposure, seek to avoid legal fees, or are simply not trained to involve legal counsel on the front-end. Indeed, we often do not hear about harassment or discrimination claims until the employee has already filed a lawsuit—which greatly increases the company’s legal exposure. An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure; if the investigation is properly conducted and concluded, the employer will have considerable protection in any future litigation
Discrimination and Harassment Investigations
Under Michigan’s Bullard-Plawecki Employee Right-to-Know Act, a Michigan employer must maintain an employee personnel file if the employer intends to use any kind of documentation to discipline or terminate that employee. In 2024 alone, 552,000 Michigan employees were involuntarily terminated. That amounts to 46,000 terminations per month.
Each of those employers were required to maintain personnel file records for each terminated employee, with the files containing, among other things, items relating to or justifying the termination; failure to do so not only subjects the employer to liability under the Employee Right-to-Know Act but also prevents the employer from using records down the road in a wrongful termination lawsuit.
As part of the Employee Right-to-Know Act, employees have the right to review and copy their personnel files. It is then up to the employer to review and provide the personnel file to the employee.
Sophisticated employers recognize that employee requests for personnel files are a prelude to a lawsuit; employees will often request the personnel file shortly before filing a lawsuit in order to see what kind of evidence the employer has against the employee. In a sense, the personnel file is a free peek at the employer’s hand.
For these reasons, companies will often engage Cronkhite Counsel to assist with review the personnel file request to ensure that the company is as protected as possible from a potential lawsuit. Compiling the personnel file is not as intuitive as it may seem. Most professionals in Human Resources, while very skilled, are not trained trial attorneys and therefore often miss opportunities to put key documents in personnel files that could later support the termination. For example, employers often omit key emails and texts because they do not view them as employment documents. But omitting those items may bar the employer from using them in a later lawsuit.
Personnel File Requests
Discrimination claims, harassment claims, and personnel file requests all call for differing types and degrees of investigation. Cronkhite Counsel is here to assist employers manage what can be an overwhelming process fraught with peril.