Issue: Alleged breach of non-competition agreement in trucking contracts.
Industry: Trucking
Case Summary
Cronkhite Counsel defended a trucking company when a competitor trucking company sued, falsely claiming that its former independent contractor had violated its non-competition agreement by launching its own trucking business and doing business with the competitor’s customers.
The non-competition clause read as follows:
Independent Contractor agrees that for a period of one (1) year subsequent to any termination of this Agreement that he or she shall not solicit nor haul any traffic for any account for which it hauled on behalf of [competitor trucking company] during the term of this agreement. If Independent Contractor breaches this section by performing services for any [competitor trucking company] account after termination of this Agreement, Independent Contractor shall remit to [competitor trucking company] 10% of all revenues invoiced to [competitor trucking company’s] account by Independent Contractor which shall continue for the existence of the Independent Contractor’s and the Account Customer’s relationship.
The competitor trucking company sued in the wrong place and violated its promise to arbitrate all disputes; it instead improperly sued in Monroe County Circuit Court, leading to Cronkhite Counsel dismissing the lawsuit and compelling the dispute into arbitration.
At the arbitration hearing, Cronkhite Counsel successfully argued that the non-competition clause was inapplicable and illegal. The non-competition clause was inapplicable because the competitor trucking company sought to apply it to a different company’s customers rather than its own clientele. And the non-competition clause was illegal because it imposed an unreasonable penalty if breached–a lifetime 10% tithe–rather than awarding damages that matched damages actually caused by the breach.
The arbitrator agreed with Cronkhite Counsel and refused to find in favor of the competitor trucking company, ruling that the “non-competition clauses for the three separate trucking contracts . . . are deemed unenforceable as a matter of law.”
Later, the Wayne County Circuit Court confirmed the arbitrator’s judgment.
Case’s Claims
- Breach of Contract (Trucking Contracts)
- Breach of Non-Competition Covenant
Key Arbitrator Quotes from Judgment
“Quite simply, there was no evidence presented that [the competitor trucking company] had some form of a confidential customer list, trade secret, pricing scheme, or any other proprietary interest that needed protection via a non-competition agreement.”
***
“It seems clear that the non-competition provision seeks to impose a penalty and to otherwise discourage any competition . . . competition that could well exist by any new start-up company. Clearly, the contract is an unfair attempt at stifling competition.”
***
“The non-competition clauses for the three separate trucking contracts . . . are deemed unenforceable as a matter of law.”
Turning Points and Key Evidence
Key evidence that came to light during the case included the following:
- In depositions, trucking company staff admitted the trucking company did not have contracts with any of the trucking company’s alleged customers, nor had the trucking company actually received revenue directly from the alleged customers.
- The trucking company’s staff also admitted that the trucking company’s affiliate company continued to do business with the allegedly diverted customers. In fact, the trucking company’s revenues had actually increased following the dispatcher’s departure from the company. In the judgment, the arbitrator observed that the competitor trucking company’s owner “could not identify any financial damages” but rather “stated that that the company profits actually increased.”
- During the arbitration hearing, the competitor trucking company’s owner admitted that the non-competition covenant was drafted to “cast a wide net,” and that the damages clause in it was intended to penalize. The arbitrator placed heavy emphasize on these admissions, noting that the non-competition agreement’s damages provision “was intended as a penalty,” rendering it illegal and unenforceable.
Key Legal Arguments
1. The Rule of Reason: The Non-Competition Clause Did Not Serve Legitimate Competitive Purposes
Michigan’s Antitrust Reform Act, MCL 445.772 et seq. (“MARA”), provides that “[a] contract, combination, or conspiracy between 2 or more persons in restraint of, or to monopolize, trade or commerce in a relevant market is unlawful.” As such, non-competition covenants may potentially violate MARA. MCL 445.772.
Because the Trucking Contracts were between two companies, the arbitrator was required to apply the federal rule of reason to determine their enforceability under MARA. Innovation Ventures, Ltd. Liab Co v Liquid Mfg Ltd Liab Co, 499 Mich 491; 514-15, 885 NW2d 861 (2016) (citing Perceptron, Inc v Sensor Adaptive Machines, Inc, 221 F3d 913, 919 (CA 6, 2000) and County Materials Corp v Allan Block Corp, 502 F3d 730, 735 (CA 7, 2007) (holding that a noncompete agreement between two companies was required to be evaluated under the rule of reason)).
“When applying the rule of reason, a court must ‘tak[e] into account a variety of factors, including specific information about the relevant business, its condition before and after the restraint was imposed, and the restraint’s history, nature, and effect.’” Id. (citing State Oil Co v Khan, 522 US 3, 10; 118 S Ct 275; 139 L Ed 2d 199 (1997)). “When employing the rule of reason, the factfinder ‘weighs all the circumstances of a case in deciding whether a restrictive practice should be prohibited as imposing an unreasonable restraint on competition.’” NorthStar Energy LLC v Encana Corp., No. 1:13-cv-200, 2014 US Dist LEXIS 39428, at *10-11 (WD Mich Mar 10, 2014) (citing Leegin Creative Leather Prods, Inc v PSKS, Inc, 551 US 877, 885, 127 S Ct. 2705, 168 L Ed 2d 623 (2007)).
In this case, Cronkhite Counsel argued that the competitor trucking company’s non-competition clause did not protect any reasonable competitive interest but rather was intended to illegally stifle competition. Indeed, the competitor trucking company had sought to over-extend the non-competition clause to prevent Cronkhite Counsel’s client from doing business with the customers of the competitor’s affiliate–not the competitor trucking company’s clients.
2. Liquidated Damages: Penalty vs. Reasonable Estimation of Damages
In terms of the non-competition clause’s 10% tithe, Cronkhite Counsel argued the 10% tithe functioned as an illegal, unenforceable penalty rather than as a reasonable estimation of potential injuries. Cf. Daoudi v. Adkins, No. 276953, 2008 Mich App LEXIS 1428, at *8-9 (Ct. App. July 15, 2008) (invalidating liquidated damages provision as an illegal penalty).
As a baseline rule for contract damages, “the appropriate measure of damages for breach of contract . . . is that which would place the injured party in as good a position as it would have been in had the promised performance been rendered.” Jim-Bob, Inc v Mehling, 178 Mich App 71, 98; 443 NW2d 451 (1989). See also Allison v AEW Capital Mgmt, LLP, 481 Mich 419, 426 n 3; 751 NW2d 8 (2008).
Liquidated damage provisions must be ‘reasonable with relation to the possible injury suffered’ and not ‘unconscionable or excessive.’” UAW-GM Human Res Ctr v KSL Recreation Corp, 228 Mich App 486, 508; 579 NW2d 411 (1998) (citations omitted).
Here, the lifetime 10% tithe bore no relation to the competitor trucking company’s alleged damages. The competitor trucking company fully intended the 10% tithe to simply stop competition rather than to compensate for harm. That is not a legitimate use of a liquidated (or fixed) damages clause.
Key Takeaways
The competitor trucking company made a number of strategic errors both before the lawsuit and during the lawsuit.
- Most critically, the trucking company sued to enforce a poorly-drafted non-competition covenant. Measure twice, cut once. Before proceeding through expensive litigations, wise companies assess whether their contractual rights are legal and enforceable. The trucking company would have been wiser spending its money to draft a legal, enforceable non-competition covenant rather than suing to enforce an illegal non-competition covenant.
- The trucking company over-extended any rights it had by misusing the non-competition clause to apply to its affiliate rather than its own clientele. This was exceptionally greedy. The discovery process–including obtaining financial and invoicing records from both the competitor trucking company and its affiliate–ultimately proved that the competitor trucking company had sued to protect its affiliate rather than itself.
- Companies sometimes think severe damage clauses are beneficial because it will prevent breach in the first place. However, extreme damage provisions are risky and can be stricken down. For example, in this case, the trucking company used a liquidated damages provision designed to halt legitimate competition rather than fairly compensate it for any harm.
Cronkhite Counsel was thrilled to successfully defend its trucking company client from these competition claims so that it could focus on its new business rather than unproductive litigation.