Issue: Alleged diversion of business using trade secrets.
Industry: Trucking
Case Summary
Cronkhite Counsel dismissed all of a trucking company’s false claims against one of its former dispatchers. The dispatcher had left the company, joined a competitor trucking company, and did a great job generating business at her new employer.
Her former employer became angry and sued both the competitor trucking company and the dispatcher. The trucking company brought nine separate legal claims, alleging it suffered $2,3000,000.00 in damages. Specifically, the trucking company claimed that the dispatcher had stolen vague trade secrets while employed with the trucking company and then unfairly competed against the company by diverting its customers to the competitor trucking company.
Cronkhite Counsel vigorously defended the dispatcher in Monroe County Circuit Court. After three years of litigation, Judge William P. Nichols completely dismissed the trucking company’s claims against the dispatcher, concluding that the trucking company had failed to present sufficient evidence of wrongdoing.
Case’s Claims
- Tortious Interference with Contractual Relations
- Tortious Interference with Business Relationships
- Misappropriation of Trade Secrets
- Unfair Competition
- Breach of Fiduciary Duties
- Unjust Enrichment
- Conversion/Theft
- Conspiracy
- Injunctive Relief
Turning Points and Key Evidence
From the start of the case, there were multiple tell-tale signs that the company’s claims against the dispatcher were very weak:
- The dispatcher had not signed any contract with the company. This meant that the company could not sue to enforce a non-competition or non-solicitation provision to prevent the default rule that parties are free to compete. Because of this fact, the trucking company was forced to be, let us say, “creative” in asserting different types of legal theories.
- One of those theories was trade secret misappropriation. However, the company’s complaint failed to identify with any sort of specificity what their trade secrets were, let alone how a dispatcher would have stolen them.
- The trucking company also claimed that a low-level dispatcher owed “fiduciary duties” to the company—and had breached them. But it is a basic principle of Michigan law that low-level employees do not owe fiduciary duties to employers.
In discovery, Cronkhite Counsel aggressively pushed for documentation and took multiple depositions to methodically dissect the trucking company’s claims. The trucking company resisted discovery for many months, leading to the court entering an order against the trucking company and its owner to produce various information and documents relevant to the lawsuit.
Key evidence that came to light included the following:
- The trucking company claimed that the dispatcher had diverted a handful of particular customers. But the documentation showed that these were not the trucking company’s customers; rather, they were customers of an affiliate company.
- In depositions, trucking company staff admitted the trucking company did not have contracts with any of the alleged customers, nor had the trucking company actually received revenue directly from the alleged customers.
- The trucking company’s staff also admitted that the trucking company’s affiliate company continued to do business with the allegedly diverted customers. In fact, the trucking company’s revenues had actually increased following the dispatcher’s departure from the company.
Legal Arguments
Cronkhite Counsel argued that the trucking company had failed to show it had experienced any damages whatsoever based on the dispatcher’s conduct. In fact, near the end of the case, the trucking company claimed it experienced damages only for one particular customer that the dispatcher had allegedly diverted. However, Cronkhite Counsel obtained evidence that the customer was not the trucking company’s customer at all—and never had been. The lack of damages proved fatal to all of the trucking company’s claims.
In terms of the tortious interference claims, Cronkhite Counsel argued that it was impossible for the dispatcher to have “interfered” with customer relationships that never existed in the first place. Indeed, a necessary requirement for a tortious interference claims is either “the existence of a valid business relationship or expectancy,” or “the existence of a contract.” Dalley v Dykema Gossett, 287 Mich App 296, 323; 788 NW2d 679 (2010) (quotation marks and citation omitted); Health Call of Detroit v Atrium Home & Health Care Servs, Inc, 268 Mich App 83, 90; 706 NW2d 843 (2005).
As to the trade secret claim, Cronkhite Counsel pointed out that the trucking company had identified a total of 7 pages of alleged “trade secrets.” But those documents comprised only a customer list of a different company—not the trucking company.
As to the fiduciary duty claim, the firm successfully argued that the dispatcher did not owe any fiduciary duties to the trucking company. “The general rule is that the employer-employee relationship does not give rise to a fiduciary relationship unless the employee is a high-level employee, or if there is a specific agency relationship.” Delphi Auto PLC v Absmeier, 167 F Supp 3d 868, 884 (ED Mich 2016). See also Akno 1010 Mkt St St Louis Missouri LLC v Pourtaghi, No. 218CV13498TGBMKM, 2021 WL 3810698, at *5 (ED Mich Aug 26, 2021) (same); Bradley v Gleason Works, 175 Mich App 459, 462; 438 NW2d 330 (1989) (finding no fiduciary relationship between an employer and an employee); Dana Ltd v Am Axle & Mfg Holdgins, Inc, No. 1:10-CV-450, 2012 WL 2524008, at *4 (WD Mich June 29, 2012) (“A high-level employee, means “corporate officers and members of corporate boards of directors[.]”).
Ultimately, the trial court agreed that the trucking company had failed to assert any claims that were worthy of going to trial and dismissed all nine of the trucking company’s claims against the dispatcher. This resulted in dismissal of $2,300,000.00 in claims against the dispatcher.
Key Takeaways
Employers often become upset and vindictive when they lose staff, particularly when their former staff assist a competitor. But it’s not wrong, in and of itself, to lawfully compete. Indeed, this is a fundamental principal of American economics and society.
The trucking company made multiple missteps both before and during the lawsuit that other companies should learn from:
- Have employees sign employment contracts, including non-competition and non-solicitation provisions, if you seek to prevent lawful competition. The trucking company failed to do so and therefore was “forced” to assert extremely weak legal claims against the dispatcher.
- While the exact amount of the trucking company’s investment into this abortive lawsuit is unknown, Cronkhite Counsel predicts it spent approximately $150,000.00 pursuing its claims. Companies should beware of investing thousands of dollars into legally weak and factually unsupported claims—a bad investment indeed. It is better to invest that money into the business, including new hires, training, and business development.
Cronkhite Counsel was privileged to defend the dispatcher against these claims, as well as her new employer from a separate lawsuit. But that is a story for a different day.